Please refer to the recent decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in SBI v. The Consortium of Mr. Murari Lal, 2024 INSC 852, where it has been held:
"183. The Members often lack the domain knowledge required to appreciate the nuanced complexities involved in high-stake insolvency matters in order to properly adjudicate such matters. It has been noticed that the benches of NCLT(s) and NCLAT don’t have the practice of sitting for the full working ours. They are particularly lacking in the capacity to manage the growing number of cases and giving undivided attention required in such matters. There are serious issues in the manner in which the insolvency matters are listed. There is no effective system in place before the NCLTs for urgent listings."
Since liberalisation and globalisation, and after the advent of national law schools, there has been a considerable expansion in the legal profession. One such set of legal professionals are the in house counsels. They are not just legal professionals but also combine as excellent management professionals.
Unfortunately, the Indian legal system has not been able to tap this excellent resource for selection in tribunals and courts. On the one hands higher courts such as High Courts and Supreme Court keep complaining about the lack of professionalism in the tribunal members but on the other hand, excellent and well-qualified professionals are, it is understood, not eligible for being appointed as judicial members of tribunals. It appears as per the current state of law that they are at the most eligible for appointment as technical members.
In this background, the following two solutions could possibly be considered: One, In house counsels could be considered for selection as technical members, in the short run, so that the tribunals are equipped with people who understand not only the mechanics of law but also of business, and two, in the long run, the relevant statutes/ rules can be amended to enable appointment of in house counsels as judicial members of such tribunals.
