"I realise that some of my criticisms may be mistaken; but to refuse to criticize judgements for fear of being mistaken is to abandon criticism altogether... If any of my criticisms are found to be correct, the cause is served; and if any are found to be incorrect the very process of finding out my mistakes must lead to the discovery of the right reasons, or better reasons than I have been able to give, and the cause is served just as well."

-Mr. HM Seervai, Preface to the 1st ed., Constitutional Law of India.

Friday, March 14, 2025

Reciprocal Provisions under S 44 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996

Over the last decade, we have been receiving queries regarding jurisdictions which are declared under Section 44(b) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. Readers have also sought copy of the notifications. This post seeks to put an end to all the queries. Available notifications can be accessed from here and here. The list of jurisdictions which are recognised through gazette notifications is given below. Rarely, awards/ arbitrations in some jurisdictions were indirectly recognised by courts even though the point regarding notification may not have been raised is also given. 

S. No.

Country/ Jurisdiction

Gazette Notification Ref.

Judgment Reference

1

Australia

Ministry of Law & Justice Notification No. SO 2252(E) dt. 12.09.2008

 

2

Austria

Ministry of Foreign Trade Notification No. S.O. 732 (E) dt. 24.11.1972

 

3

Belgium

Ministry of Commerce & Supplies Notification No. S.O. 290 (E) dt. 28.04.1980

 

4

Botswana

Ministry of Commerce No. S.O. 42(E) dt. 07.01.1978

 

5

Bulgaria

Ministry of Foreign Trade Notification No. S.O. 428 (E) dt. 14.06.1972

 

6

Canada

Ministry of Law & Justice Notification No. SO 327(E) dt. 26.03.2003

 

7

Central African Republic

Ministry of Commerce No. S.O. 85 (E) dt. 03.02.1983

 

 

8

Cuba

Ministry of Commerce No. S.O. 42(E) dt. 07.01.1978

 

9

Denmark

Ministry of Commerce No. S.O. 42(E) dt. 07.01.1978

 

10

Dubai

 

Mulheim Pipecoatings GmbH. vs. Welspun Fintrade Limited and Ors. (16.08.2013 - BOMHC) : MANU/MH/1285/2013

11

Ecuador

Ministry of Foreign Trade Notification No. S.O. 428 (E) dt. 14.06.1972

 

12

Egypt

Ministry of Commerce No. S.O. 42(E) dt. 07.01.1978

 

13

Finland

 

Finnish Fund for Industrial Corporation Ltd. vs. VME Precast Pvt. Ltd. and Ors. (14.10.2020 - MADHC) : MANU/TN/5710/2020

14

France (Paris)

 

W.P.I.L. vs. NTPC Ltd. and Ors. (16.01.2009 - DELHC) : MANU/DE/0078/2009

15

German Democratic Republic

Ministry of Commerce No. S.O. 42(E) dt. 07.01.1978

 

16

Ghana

Ministry of Commerce No. S.O. 282 (E) dt. 16.05.1973

 

17

Greece

 

Ministry of Foreign Trade Notification No. S.O. 428 (E) dt. 14.06.1972

 

18

Japan

Ministry of Foreign Trade Notification No. S.O. 732 (E) dt. 24.11.1972

Aksh Optifibre Ltd. vs. Shin Etsu Chemical Co., Ltd. and Ors. (12.01.2005 - RAJHC) : MANU/RH/0032/2005

19

Kuwait

Ministry of Commerce No. S.O. 86 (E) dt. 03.02.1983 &

Ministry of Law & Justice Notification No. GSR894(E) dt. 06.12.2022 (published on 22.12.2022), MANU/LAFF/0034/2022

 

20

Malagasy Republic

Ministry of Commerce No. S.O. 42(E) dt. 07.01.1978

 

21

Malaysia

Ministry of Law & Justice Notification No. SO 754(E) dt. 11.08.2000

 

22

Mauritius

Ministry of Law & Justice Notification No. SO 1881(E) dt. 13.07.2015

 

23

Mexico

Ministry of Commerce No. S.O. 42(E) dt. 07.01.1978

 

24

Morrocco

Ministry of Commerce No. S.O. 282 (E) dt. 16.05.1973

 

25

Nigeria

Ministry of Commerce No. S.O. 282 (E) dt. 16.05.1973

 

26

Norway

Ministry of Foreign Trade Notification No. S.O. 428 (E) dt. 14.06.1972

 

27

People's Republic of China (including

Hongkong SAR &  Macao SAR

Ministry of Law & Justice Notification No. SO 580(E) dt. 19.03.2012

 

28

Philippines

Ministry of Foreign Trade Notification No. S.O. 732 (E) dt. 24.11.1972

 

29

Poland

Ministry of Commerce Notification No. S.O. 1238 dt. 29.02.1968

 

30

Rumania

Ministry of Foreign Trade Notification No. S.O. 428 (E) dt. 14.06.1972

 

31

San Marino

Ministry of Commerce Notification No. S.O. 84 (E) dt. 03.02.1983

 

32

Singapore

Ministry of Law & Justice Notification No. SO 542(E) dt. 06.07.1999

 

33

Sweden

Ministry of Foreign Trade Notification No. S.O. 732 (E) dt. 24.11.1972

 

34

Switzerland

 

Pasl Wind Solutions Private Limited vs. GE Power Conversion India Private Limited, [2021] 4 S.C.R. 532 : MANU/SC/0295/2021(strictly, not a decision enforcing a foreign award)

35

Syria

Ministry of Commerce, Supplies & Co-operation Notification No. S.O. 2920 dt. 25.09.1978

 

36

Tanzania

Ministry of Foreign Trade Notification No. S.O. 732 (E) dt. 24.11.1972

 

37

Thailand

Ministry of Foreign Trade Notification No. S.O. 732 (E) dt. 24.11.1972

 

38

The Netherlands

Ministry of Foreign Trade Notification No. S.O. 732 (E) dt. 24.11.1972

 

39

Trinidad & Tobago

Ministry of Commerce No. S.O. 42(E) dt. 07.01.1978

 

40

Tunisia

Ministry of Commerce No. S.O. 282 (E) dt. 16.05.1973

 

41

United Kingdom

Ministry of Commerce No. S.O. 4302 dt. 25.10.1976

 

42

United States of America

Ministry of Foreign Trade Notification No. S.O. 732 (E) dt. 24.11.1972

International Nut Alliance LLC vs. Johns Cashew Company (09.12.2021 - KERHC) : MANU/KE/3139/2021; Integrated Sales Services Limited  vs.  DMC Management Consultants Ltd. and Ors. (18.04.2016 - BOMHC) : MANU/MH/0557/2016 

 In case readers come across other jurisdictions relating to this, please let us know.